Lena Dunham s NYT Op-Ed on the Obamacare Mandate is Based on Two Falsehoods #birth #control,catholicism,john #mccormack,mandate,obamacare,lena #dunham,home #page,today #s #blogs


#

Stephen F. Hayes

Richard Starr

Fred Barnes

Christopher Caldwell

Andrew Ferguson

Lee Smith

Philip Terzian

Kelly Jane Torrance

Jay Cost

Mark Hemingway

Matt Labash

John McCormack

Michael Warren

Jonathan V. Last

Ethan Epstein

Jim Swift

William Kristol

Lena Dunham’s NYT Op-Ed on the Obamacare Mandate is Based on Two Falsehoods

Lena Dunham, the HBO celebrity and Democratic activist, had an op-ed in the New York Times over the weekend arguing against a regulation under consideration by the Trump administration. According to a leak, conscientious objectors could opt out of the Obamacare mandate that forces American employers to provide insurance that covers contraceptives and some abortifacients with no copayment.

Dunham is certainly entitled to her own opinion, but her New York Times op-ed is premised on two errors of fact. She writes:

[F]or millions of women living with endometriosis, polycystic ovarian syndrome, cystic acne, migraines, uterine abnormalities and a history of ectopic pregnancies, birth control can be a crucial, even lifesaving, medical treatment. While there is no cure for endometriosis, hormonal contraception can control pain and bleeding by stopping or significantly shortening the length of a woman’s period. It helps keep women with the disease happy, healthy and able to work. Considering how little money the government puts into endometriosis research (last year, the National Institutes of Health allocated around $10 million of its $32 billion budget to it), it’s clear that our country already has a dangerous disregard for women with this common condition. But imagine if this disease that affects about one in 10 women of reproductive age were allowed to progress unhindered. Imagine losing these women’s essential contributions to our world because of a treatable illness.
Well, if the Trump administration follows through on its plan to roll back the requirement that insurers cover birth control (revealed in leaked government documents last week), you won’t have to imagine it. The documents outline a chilling proposal that would allow any employer to deny coverage of birth control at any time and for any reason. Women who rely on oral contraception would suddenly be living in a very different reality, one in which some could become disabled as their disease progressed.

It is simply false for Dunham to claim that the draft regulation would “allow any employer to deny coverage of birth control at any time and for any reason.” Pages 119 and 120 of the draft regulation clearly state that the “religious beliefs” or “moral convictions” of conscientious objectors must be “sincerely held.” The draft regulation does not say “any employer” can opt out for “any reason.” Limited-government conservatives would of course prefer a simple repeal of this federal mandate and many others, but that’s not what’s being considered.

As the lawyer who represents the Little Sisters of the Poor, an order of nuns that serves the elderly poor and objects to Obamacare’s contraceptive mandate, recently told reporters: Under the proposed regulation the government would determine whether the religious beliefs and moral convictions are “sincerely held” the “same exact way they determine whether religious or moral objections are made in good faith under lots of different federal statutes and regulations.”

The lawyer, Mark Rienzi of the Becket Fund, added that “every day courts engage in analysis to figure out whether someone has a sincere religious belief or somebody’s just trying to dodge military service, or get out of doing something in their work, or if a prisoner is just trying to trick their way into better food rather than having a sincere religious exemption.”

Before the mandate, the vast majority of private insurance plans covered contraceptives, and the federal government spent hundreds of millions of dollars on contraceptives under Medicaid and the Title X program. Dunham claims that “for women living near or below the poverty line, [the regulation] would be disastrous, jeopardizing their ability to work and provide for their families,” but the regulation wouldn’t affect anyone benefiting from Medicaid or Title X.

According to Gallup, 89 percent of Americans believe birth control is morally acceptable, so we are only talking about a tiny percentage of American employers who might opt out from the mandate. As Politico reported in October 2016, in the two years since the Supreme Court ruled that Obamacare’s contraceptive mandate was a violation of the Religious Freedom Restoration Act, “only 52 companies and nonprofit organizations, have told the government they plan to opt out of Obamacare’s requirement to cover birth control because it violates their religious beliefs.” Corporations are not going to state false moral or religious objections to birth control 1) because they could be subject to charges of perjury and 2) because it’s widely believed that birth control subsidies save insurers and employers money.

That brings us to the second false (if implicit) premise of Dunham’s op-ed, which is that Catholics object to use hormonal contraceptives to treat diseases. The first result of a simple Google search would have revealed to Dunham that that’s not true. “Catholic teaching does not oppose the use of hormonal medications—such as those found in chemical contraceptives—for legitimate medical purposes,” reads the website of the United States Council of Catholic Bishops. And as a Supreme Court brief on behalf of Catholic plaintiffs opposed to the contraceptive mandate states: “Consistent with Catholic teaching, in certain circumstances Petitioners’ plans cover products commonly used as contraceptives when prescribed for noncontraceptive, medically necessary purposes.”

If Dunham wants to argue that Catholic nuns should be forced to violate their religious beliefs so that middle- and high-income women don’t have to pay $9 a month for contraception, she has every right to do that. But Dunham and the New York Times should not misrepresent what the Trump administration is actually considering and what Catholics actually believe.

Web Link: http://www.weeklystandard.com/article/2008439

Share

Respond

Like Us

Stephen F. Hayes

Richard Starr

Fred Barnes

Christopher Caldwell

Andrew Ferguson

Lee Smith

Philip Terzian

Kelly Jane Torrance

Jay Cost

Mark Hemingway

Matt Labash

John McCormack

Michael Warren

Jonathan V. Last

Ethan Epstein

Jim Swift

William Kristol


International Visa Service – Same day service for visas, passports and other travel documents, located in Atlanta, Georgia #travel #visa, #passport, #u.s., #same #day #service, #document #processing, #visalady, #forms, #atlanta, #sandy #springs, #georgia, #travel #documents, #foreign, #emergency #service, #authentications, #legalizations, #police #clearence #records, #certified #birth #certificates, #civil #records, #apostilles, #photographs, #court #documents, #research #visa #requirements, #translations, #state #department #travel #forms, #24 #hour #service


#

Welcome to International Visa Service

Serving Clients
and Documentation Needs Worldwide

International Visa Service provides QUICK SERVICE for documentation from all over the world. This service is efficient and cost effective. Your document problem and its solution is our business .

Services are available in all 50 States. Additional business days may be required in Alaska and Hawaii due to logistics. All Documents are hand-carried by a representative of International Visa Service. If English is not your first language, our staff speaks several languages including Spanish, French, Arabic, Farsi, Greek—just to name a few.

International Visa Service, Inc. is registered, but not affiliated, with the US Department of State and US Passport Services. We are a privately owned company that has been in business since 1976. We charge an additional fee to expedite your passport in 1-10 days.

If you are not in a time crunch, you can obtain a passport directly from the U.S. Department of State in roughly 4-6 weeks, with no additional fee. Please feel free to visit your local post office or the official U.S. Department of State website if you do not require your passport in an expedited time frame. To contact foreign embassies, click here for .PDF list with embassy contact information.

International Visa Service offers emergency same day service, seven days a week for clients who can demonstrate a real emergency. Normal Service is from 24 hours to 10 business days.

Services are available in the 48 States. Additional business days may be required in Alaska and Hawaii due to logistics. All Documents are hand-carried by a representative of International Visa Service. If English is not your first language, our staff speaks several languages including Spanish, French, Arabic, Farsi, Greek—just to name a few.

We Are Ready To Serve You

Visit Our Sandy Springs, Georgia Location

Monday-Friday 8:30 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. We are closed on Saturday during the winter and we are closed on Sunday. While we wish to help every customer with their passport needs, first time and children passport applicants must arrive BEFORE 3:00 PM. We must have two hours before our office closes in order for us to have time to process your paperwork. We are open for pick ups only after 4:00 p.m.

Hartsfield Jackson International Airport, Atlanta, Georgia

The office at Hartsfield Jackson International Airport has been closed.

Do You Need a
Business or Tourist Visa?

Find the Business or Tourist travel requirements for the country you are traveling to using the country selection list below. NOTE: Your web browser must have popups enabled in order for the requirements to be seen. Be sure to contact our office to confirm your visa requirements as visa requirements are subject to change as our website requirements system may not have the latest information.

Business Visa
Requirements Search

Tourist Visa
Requirements Search

WARNING

A major warning is in the front of your passport: “BEFORE YOU TRAVEL ABROAD” In this section there is a warning concerning insurance. “Medical Costs abroad can be extremely expensive! [ Read More ]

Copyright 2000-2015 by T.I.S. Inc. All rights reserved.

No part of this website may be reproduced without written permission by T.I.S. Inc.